Categories Courts World

Trump makes final pitch to SC in fraught immunity case

Former President Donald Trump made his final pitch Thursday to the Supreme Court in his effort to pause a trial over the election subversion charges brought by special counsel Jack Smith.

“There are overwhelming reasons why the case should not go to trial ‘in three months or less,’” Trump told the Supreme Court in a 16-page filing. “With any other defendant, it would be virtually unthinkable for the case to go to trial so soon, and ‘wildly unfair’ to do so.”

CNN reported Trump claims former presidents must have immunity from such charges to avoid political reprisals when they leave office. So far, two lower federal courts have balked at that argument. The Supreme Court is expected to decide on Trump’s request within a few days.

With Trump’s final brief in hand, a question of timing is now squarely before the high court. The justices could deny Trump’s emergency request to temporarily block a DC Circuit ruling against him on the immunity issue or they could agree to further consider his case.

The first outcome would clear the way for a US District court in Washington, DC, to schedule a trial on the underlying election charges, which Smith is eager to resolve before the November election. The second could signal the justices may schedule oral arguments in the case later this year, potentially pushing a trial back several months.

On Monday, Trump asked the Supreme Court to block a unanimous decision from the DC Circuit handed down last week that rejected his claims of immunity from the election subversion charges. “Without immunity from criminal prosecution, the presidency as we know it will cease to exist,” Trump told the Supreme Court. Two days later – ahead of deadline – Smith argued in his own brief that Trump had not met the standard to pause proceedings in his case. It generally takes support from five justices to secure such a pause.

“The charged crimes strike at the heart of our democracy,” Smith wrote in a filing Wednesday. “The public interest in a prompt trial is at its zenith where, as here, a former president is charged with conspiring to subvert the electoral process so that he could remain in office.”

Author

Managing Partner - Mohla & Mohla - Advocates and Legal Consultants, Islamabad-Pakistan. Founder  ‘The Law Today Pakistan’ (TLTP) Newswire Service. Teaches Jurisprudence, International law, Civil and Criminal law.  Can be reached at mohla@lawtoday.com.pk

More From Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

HSU Advocates, Hassan Sharafat & Umer Advocates, Islamabad Bar Council elections 2025, Islamabad Bar Council, HSU Annual Get Together, Gun and Country Club Islamabad, law firm event Islamabad, Sharafat A Chaudhry, legal fraternity Pakistan, bar politics Pakistan, rule of law Pakistan, Islamabad lawyers, top law firms in Islamabad, legal profession news Pakistan, Bar Council leadership, consultative process Bar Council, democratic values in law, HSU law firm news, professional fellowship lawyers, upcoming Bar Council elections, Khudayar Mohla

HSU Advocates Hosts Annual Get Together Ahead of IBC Elections

HSU Advocates held its Annual Get Together at the Gun and Country Club, Islamabad, in…

NIRC Pakistan, National Industrial Relations Commission, Zubair Khan NIRC, Abdul Qayyum Khan NIRC, Justice Shaukat Aziz Siddiqui, Chaudhry Salik Hussain, industrial dispute resolution Pakistan, labour justice Pakistan, video link court hearings, NIRC farewell ceremony, labour law Pakistan, judicial reform Pakistan, industrial harmony Pakistan, prompt justice NIRC, Overseas Pakistanis Ministry, Islamabad legal news, Pakistani trade unions, labour courts Pakistan, workers’ rights Pakistan, Islamabad High Court Bar, labour dispute commission Pakistan, Khudayar Mohla

Honouring a Legacy: NIRC Celebrates Service of Zubair Khan and Abdul Qayyum Khan

Speakers at a farewell ceremony on Thursday in honour of two outgoing National Industrial Relations…

Editor, Khudayar Mohla, Farooq Ali case, UK national found dead Islamabad, Farooq Ali murder trial, Dr Rehiana B Ali, suspicious hotel death Pakistan, Islamabad hotel death, postmortem denied by police, FIR 204/22, Section 302 PPC, Section 34 PPC, Islamabad High Court case, forensic investigation failures Pakistan, cover-up by hotel staff, police negligence in murder case, Advocate Sharafat Ali Chaudhry, exhumation report Pakistan, CCTV evidence tampering, Ramada Hotel Islamabad death, private complaint under Section 200 CrPC, justice for Farooq Ali, Pakistani judicial system test, delayed FIR registration, death investigation Pakistan, court verdict May 29 2025, murder cover-up allegations, critical evidence destroyed, criminal justice accountability Pakistan, medico-legal investigation flaws

Verdict Awaited in High-Profile Farooq Ali Murder Case

UK citizen's sister alleges foul play, police cover-up, and forensic mishandling; court to announce judgment…