Bloodstain DNA Match Alone Cannot Sustain Murder Conviction, SC Rules
Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim says doubtful recovery of clothes and unnatural eyewitness conduct left the prosecution's chain of evidence broken

Khudayar Mohla

ISLAMABAD: While acquitting a convict who had been sentenced to life imprisonment in a murder case from Jhang, the Supreme Court of Pakistan held that a bloodstain DNA match, taken in isolation, cannot be treated as conclusive incriminating evidence in the absence of independent, cogent and corroborative material linking the accused to the offence.

A three-member bench comprising Justice Muhammad Hashim Khan Kakkar, Justice Salahuddin Panhwar and Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim heard the matter on 29 September 2026.

Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim is the author judge of this 7-page verdict with assistance of Law Clerk Ms. Tayyaba Munir.

Advocate Supreme Court Ajmal Kanju represented the in J.P. 495 of 2021, whereas Zafar Mahmood Chaudhry appeared in Crl.P.L.A. 1483-L of 2021. Additional Prosecutor General Punjab Tariq Siddique along with Deputy Prosecutor General Punjab Hamayoun Aslam.

Petitioner Ghulam Shabbir was charged in FIR No. 71 dated 15.02.2017, registered at Police Station Sadar, District Jhang, under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code for the Qatl-i-Amd of Mst. Tasleem Akhtar. The Sessions Judge, Jhang, convicted him under Section 302(b) PPC on 25.09.2017 and sentenced him to death as tazir, with Rs. 100,000 compensation payable to the legal heirs under Section 544-A Cr.P.C.

The Lahore High Court, in its judgment dated 23.09.2021, upheld the conviction but altered the sentence from death to imprisonment for life, with the benefit of Section 382-B Cr.P.C. The convict then approached the Supreme Court through J.P. 495 of 2021. A connected petition, Crl.P.L.A. 1483-L of 2021, was filed by complainant Mazhar Abbas.

The prosecution case rested on three eyewitnesses who allegedly saw the petitioner strangling the deceased with a rope. The Court found it not possible that three adult men would watch such an incident, particularly involving a relative, without intervening or attempting to apprehend the accused. It noted that the petitioner allegedly escaped over a 7-foot wall in their presence. While the husband’s conduct in lodging the FIR was understandable, the Court termed his conduct at the time of the occurrence “entirely unnatural” and contrary to ordinary human conduct.

With the eyewitness account set aside, the case turned on a bloodstained jersey whose stain matched the victim’s DNA. The Court found the recovery unconvincing for four reasons. The eyewitnesses never described the clothes worn by the accused, so it could not be established that the recovered garments were his.

The clothes were allegedly recovered from an unlocked iron trunk in a house not in the petitioner’s exclusive possession, and no independent private witnesses were associated with the recovery. The accused remained unarrested for 15 days, making it improbable that he would leave incriminating clothing unsecured at his home. Finally, the record was silent on the condition of the garments at recovery and on how they were stored in the malkhana before being sent for forensic testing.

The Court also noted that the DNA profile from the rope was a mixture of three individuals, of whom only the major component matched the victim, while two contributors remained unidentified. It observed that the Punjab Forensic Science Agency had asked for buccal swab standards from the suspect and the deceased’s husband, but neither sample was subsequently provided. Taken cumulatively, the Court held, these deficiencies undermined the evidentiary value of the clothes and the rope.

Referring to the Indian Supreme Court’s decision in Pooranmal v. State of Rajasthan [2026 INSC 217], the Court held that a bloodstain DNA match is strong evidence when corroborated by other evidence establishing a chain linking the accused with the victim and the offence, but it cannot be taken in isolation as incriminating evidence. The evidentiary value of such a match depends not only on its scientific reliability but also on the integrity of the recovery and the circumstances connecting the recovered articles to the accused.

The Court converted the petition into an appeal and allowed it, acquitting the appellant of the charge and directing his release forthwith, if not required in any other case. Crl.P.L.A. 1483-L of 2021, seeking enhancement of sentence, was dismissed and leave refused.

Share This Article
Managing Partner at Mohla & Mohla Advocates and Legal Consultants, Islamabad, and Founder of "The Law Today Pakistan" (TLTP) Newswire Service. Former President, Press Association of the Supreme Court of Pakistan, with over two decades covering landmark judicial moments. Mohla is an accomplished Right to Information Advocate of the High Courts, and has taught jurisprudence, constitutional law, procedural laws, and international law to hundreds of law students at public sector universities in Islamabad. Holds an LLB, LLM, and M.A. in Mass Communication. Contact: mohla@lawtoday.com.pk
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *