Categories Courts

SC Bins Brother Plea, Upholds Sister’ Inheritance Right

ISLAMABAD – A woman, whether as a sister, daughter, mother or wife, is entitled to her rightful share in inheritance, a fundamental right enshrined in both religion and law of the land. Practically, yet, in much of Pakistan, this legal and moral principle remains distant from reality.

Across society, there is a pervasive and unjust belief that the expenses of a sister’s marriage can be offset by transferring her property rights to male family members – a practice that, while socially entrenched, represents a profound social injustice that must come to an end.

A day ago, the Supreme Court took a significant step in challenging this practice by dismissing an appeal seeking denial his sister’ share in inherited property. A two-member bench comprising the esteemed Justice Hasan Azhar Rizvi and Justice Naeem Akhtar Afghan delivered the verdict, who jointly rejected the plea. In their ruling, they held that a brother has no legal or moral grounds to deprive his sister of her lawful rights.

During the proceedings, Justice Afghan highlighted the glaring hypocrisy present in society, noting with poignant clarity that “the brother expects his sisters to serve him but refuses to give them their rightful share in the property while the sisters cook and clean the house.” His observation underscored the gender disparity and the unwritten social contract that often leaves women economically vulnerable.

Justice Rizvi added a powerful religious and legal dimension to the ruling, emphasizing that the Qur’an has unequivocally defined women’s shares in inheritance. He posed a rhetorical yet profound question, “How can one deny what is ordained by the Qur’an?” Justice Rizvi also pointed out a critical procedural flaw in the petitioner’s case: the sister’s signature was missing on the property distribution document, a detail that conclusively indicated a lack of consent on her part and invalidated the claim that she had willingly relinquished her rights.

Counsel for the petitioner argued that the sister, identified as Maryam, had already received her share, but she insisted that the amount was insufficient and did not represent her lawful entitlement. After brief hearing of the matter, the Court found no legal or factual merit in the appeal.

The bench’s decision not only upheld her rightful claim but also sent a strong message across the country: women cannot and will not be deprived of the inheritance guaranteed to them by law and religion. This landmark decision serves as a crucial reaffirmation of women’s property rights and is a powerful stride toward a more just and equitable society where entrenched social practices do not override fundamental human rights.

Author

Khudayar Mohla, Managing Partner Mohla & Mohla, Founder of the Law Today Pakistan,

Managing Partner – Mohla & Mohla – Advocates and Legal Consultants, Islamabad, Pakistan. A Satirist and Founder of The Law Today Pakistan (TLTP) Newswire Service. Teaches Jurisprudence, International Law, Civil and Criminal Law. Can be reached at mohla@lawtoday.com.pk.

More From Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Lahore High Court, Justice Abher Gul Khan, Sajjad Ali acquittal, murder conviction overturned, reasonable doubt, flawed investigation, evidentiary failures, delayed FIR, post-mortem delay, withholding witnesses, unsubstantiated motive, unreliable testimony, forensic gaps, Khudayar Mohla

LHC Acquits Murder Convict as Prosecution Failed to Prove the Story

LAHORE – A single-member bench of the Lahore High Court comprising Justice Abher Gul Khan,…

Supreme Court of Pakistan, Constitutional Bench, 26th Constitutional Amendment, judicial powers, Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail, Justice Ayesha A Malik, full court, judicial independence, suo motu, Chief Justice of Pakistan, Jawwad S Khawaja, Khawaja Ahmed, constitutional challenge, Article 191A, Parliament, Article 239, Islamabad.

Federation’s Role in 26th Amendment Passage Faces Court Scrutiny

ISLAMABAD – Resuming the hearing in response to over three dozen identical pleas challenging the…

Supreme Court of Pakistan, Public Facilitation Portal, judicial accessibility, online gateway, Chief Justice, Cases Information, Helpline 1818, Applications Status, Early Hearing Requests, Video Link Petitions, Complaints, Anti-Corruption Reporting, Overseas Litigants Portal, justice system, digital transformation

SC Launches ‘Public Facilitation Portal’ to Revolutionize Access to Justice

ISLAMABAD – Taking a significant step toward judicial accessibility, the Supreme Court of Pakistan has…