Categories Courts

No Inquiry Needed: SC Upholds Firing of Civil Servant Over Absenteeism

Civil Servant, Supreme Court of Pakistan, National Bank of Pakistan, Zahoor Ahmed Mengal, civil servant termination, EOL without pay, extra ordinary leave, unauthorized absence, employee misconduct, judicial precedent, Pakistan law, service rules, labor law, civil service, Supreme Court judgment, court ruling, legal analysis, employment law Pakistan, civil service rules, termination without inquiry

ISLAMABAD – While addressing two key legal questions in service matter whether a regular inquiry was necessary and if treating the absence as Extra Ordinary Leave (EOL) was a form of punishment, top court upheld termination of civil servant saying there is no need to conduct regular inquiry for an admitted absence from duty.

The Supreme Court has upheld the termination of a civil servant, ruling that a regular inquiry is not required for an admitted absence from duty. The court’s decision was made in the case of National Bank of Pakistan v. Zahoor Ahmed Mengal, as detailed in the judgment dated December 30, 2019, from the High Court of Balochistan, Quetta.

The matter involved a civil servant case whose service was terminated without a formal inquiry after he was found to be absent from his post. The period of absence was treated as EOL without pay.

The Law Today Pakistan has learnt that in its verdict,  the court cited previous judgments, including Federation of Pakistan through Secretary, Ministry of Law and Justice Division, Islamabad vs. Mamoon Ahmed Malik (2020 SCMR 1154), to assert that a regular inquiry is not needed when the fact of absence is admitted, as there are no disputed facts to be investigated.

The court also referenced the cases of NAB through its Chairman vs. Muhammad Shafique (2020 SCMR 425) and Kafyat Ullah Khan vs. Inspector General of Police, Islamabad and another (Civil Appeal No.1661 of 2019).

Based on these precedents, it concluded that treating an unauthorized absence as EOL is not a punishment. Instead, it is a justified administrative action that an employer is entitled to take.

The ruling sets a clear precedent: in cases of admitted absence from duty, a regular inquiry is not mandatory, and the conversion of the absence period to EOL without pay is a legitimate action, not a punitive measure.

Author

Khudayar Mohla, Managing Partner Mohla & Mohla, Founder of the Law Today Pakistan,
Khudayar Mohla

Managing Partner at Mohla & Mohla - Advocates and Legal Consultants, Islamabad, Founder of The Law Today Pakistan (TLTP) Newswire Service. Former President Press Association of Supreme Court of Pakistan with over two decades of coverage of defining judicial moments - including the dissolution and restoration of Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, Asif Ali Zardari NAB cases, Syed Yousaf Raza Gillani contempt proceedings, Panama Papers case against Mian Nawaz Sharif, matters involving Imran Khan, and the high treason trial of former Army Chief and President Pervez Musharraf. He now practises law and teaches Jurisprudence, International Law, and Civil and Criminal Law. Contact: mohla@lawtoday.com.pk

More From Author

Reko Diq project, Pakistan gold market, CCP report, gold sector reforms, $74 billion investment, gold imports Pakistan, informal gold trade, gold smuggling Pakistan, gold value chain, hallmarking Pakistan, gold traceability blockchain, Pakistan Gold & Gemstone Authority, gold market regulation Pakistan, CECL study, gold pricing opacity, gold refinement Pakistan, AML CFT compliance, Gold Banking System Pakistan, Reko Diq economic impact, Pakistan jewelry industry, gold sector modernization

Reko Diq’s $74bn Potential Underscored as CCP Warns Pakistan’s Gold Trade Remains 90% Informal and Prone to Illicit Flows

  • November 27, 2025
Punjab Judicial Academy, Justice Aalia Neelum, Lahore High Court, PJA Board Meeting, first female Chairperson PJA, judicial training Punjab, judicial reforms Pakistan, Punjab Judicial Academy Act 2007, Section 4 PJA Act, judicial officers training, court personnel training, court management training, case management Punjab, delay reduction techniques, alternate dispute resolution training, judgment writing training, judicial administration Punjab, legal education Pakistan, Sardar Ahmed Naeem, Justice Sajid Mehmood Sethi, Justice Jawad Hassan, Amjad Iqbal Ranjha, Lahore news, judicial capacity building, Federal Judicial Academy collaboration, legal research Punjab, judicial ethics training, law and development Punjab, legislative drafting training, PJA conferences seminars workshops.

Chief Justice LHC Justice Miss Aalia Neelum Chairs PJA Board Meeting, Marks Historic First for Academy

  • November 26, 2025
Rawalpindi Police, viral assault video, three arrested, girl assaulted, hair forcibly cut, social media video, Naseerabad Police Station, Misrial Colony, Bahria Town, Rawalpindi incident, Islamabad Police clarification, victim statement, six weeks old, legal proceedings, Misrial Road flat, Pakistan crime news

Victim Traced, Suspects Held: Rawalpindi Police Act on Viral Assault Video

  • November 26, 2025

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Punjab Judicial Academy, Justice Aalia Neelum, Lahore High Court, PJA Board Meeting, first female Chairperson PJA, judicial training Punjab, judicial reforms Pakistan, Punjab Judicial Academy Act 2007, Section 4 PJA Act, judicial officers training, court personnel training, court management training, case management Punjab, delay reduction techniques, alternate dispute resolution training, judgment writing training, judicial administration Punjab, legal education Pakistan, Sardar Ahmed Naeem, Justice Sajid Mehmood Sethi, Justice Jawad Hassan, Amjad Iqbal Ranjha, Lahore news, judicial capacity building, Federal Judicial Academy collaboration, legal research Punjab, judicial ethics training, law and development Punjab, legislative drafting training, PJA conferences seminars workshops.

Chief Justice LHC Justice Miss Aalia Neelum Chairs PJA Board Meeting, Marks Historic First for Academy

  • November 26, 2025

LAHORE – Days ago the Punjab Judicial Academy marked a significant milestone when Chief Justice…

Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), 27th Constitutional Amendment, FCC commences operations, judicial arena, Islamabad High Court (IHC), FCC judges oath-taking, Justice Rozi Khan Barrech, Justice Arshad Hussain Shah, Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan, courtrooms arranged, logistical issues, teething problems, IHC Courtroom No. 2, Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar, FCC high-profile cases, amenity plots case, Sindh High Court (SHC) judgment stayed, Karachi Metropolitan Corporation (KMC), public-interest case, IHC relocation, Red Zone difficulties, Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), Justice Miangul Hassan Aurangzeb, superior judiciary Pakistan, structural change judicial framework.

Federal Constitutional Court Opens in IHC Building, Ushering in New Post-27th Amendment Judicial Order

  • November 18, 2025

ISLAMABAD – The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) finally commenced operations on Monday, marking the first…

Lahore High Court, 27th Constitutional Amendment, challenged, judicial independence, Muhammad Azhar Siddique, Munir Ahmed, Mian Shabbir Ismail, basic structure violation, Supreme Court original jurisdiction, Federal Constitutional Court, abolition of Supreme Court powers, 1973 Constitution, judicial history distortion, compromise of judiciary, legislative transparency, lack of public debate, void amendment, stay on implementation.

Constitutionality of 27th Amendment Challenged in LHC

  • November 15, 2025

LAHORE – Invoking jurisdiction of the Lahore High Court – petitioners challenged legality of the…