Categories Courts

Courts Must Exercise Discretion in Favour of Accused on Concurrent Sentences, SC Rules

ISLAMABAD –  The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled that courts are empowered to direct that sentences for multiple convictions should run concurrently rather than consecutively. This decision, announced by a three-member bench, emphasizes that judicial discretion should ordinarily be exercised in favor of the accused, especially in case of a minor.
In a reported verdict, the bench, consisting of Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail, Justice Athar Minallah, and Justice Malik Shahzad Ahmad Khan, delivered the verdict in the case of Noor Muhammad etc. v. The State (Jail Petitions Nos. 603/2017, 442/2019, 443/2019 & 444/2019). The case involved a petitioner who had been convicted in three separate cases and was sentenced to multiple prison terms, including life imprisonment.

After the High Court dismissed his appeals, he filed petitions with the apex court. In its analysis, the Supreme Court reaffirmed the principle established in Mst. Shahista Bibi’s case, which held that sentences of imprisonment or life imprisonment, whether from the same trial or separate trials, must run concurrently. The court highlighted that this principle is based on Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC).
The ruling reasserts the judiciary’s duty to balance penal consequences with fairness, ensuring that punishment for multiple offenses doesn’t become disproportionately harsh. The court stressed that the power to order concurrent sentences under Section 397 CrPC should be used to benefit the accused unless there are exceptional circumstances that warrant otherwise.

Author

Khudayar Mohla, Managing Partner Mohla & Mohla, Founder of the Law Today Pakistan,

Managing Partner at Mohla & Mohla - Advocates and Legal Consultants, Islamabad, Founder of The Law Today Pakistan (TLTP) Newswire Service. Former President Press Association of Supreme Court of Pakistan with over two decades of coverage of defining judicial moments - including the dissolution and restoration of Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, Asif Ali Zardari NAB cases, Syed Yousaf Raza Gillani contempt proceedings, Panama Papers case against Mian Nawaz Sharif, matters involving Imran Khan, and the high treason trial of former Army Chief and President Pervez Musharraf. He now practises law and teaches Jurisprudence, International Law, Civil and Criminal Law. Can be reached at: mohla@lawtoday.com.pk

More From Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Tayyaba Munir, Khudayar Mohla, Supreme Court of Pakistan, Judiciary-Sponsored Orphanhood, Section 306 PPC, Death Sentence Commuted, Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim, Criminal Law Pakistan, UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Life Imprisonment, Vehari Murder Case, Qisas and Diyat Law

SC Coins ‘Judiciary-Sponsored Orphanhood’ Doctrine to Commute Father’s Death Sentence

Supreme Court · Criminal Law · Pakistan ISLAMABAD: While deciding a jail appeal, Supreme Court…

difference between dismissed for non-prosecution and consigned to record, Lahore High Court civil procedure ruling, restoration of suit under CPC Pakistan, administrative consignment of case file, LHC ruling on waqf graveyard land dispute, Khudayar Mohla, Lahore High Court, LHC judgment, Civil Procedure Code Pakistan, Order IX CPC, dismissed for non-prosecution, consigned to record meaning, restoration of civil suit, Justice Anwaar Hussain, waqf graveyard dispute, Pakistan civil litigation

LHC Rules ‘Dismissal for Non-Prosecution’ and ‘Consigning to Record’ Have Distinct Legal Consequences

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has held that the expressions ‘dismissed for non-prosecution’ and ‘consigned…

petroleum price hike Pakistan, fuel price litigation Pakistan, Lahore High Court petition, petrol price increase case, petroleum levy controversy Pakistan, constitutional challenge fuel prices

JAF Moves LHC, Questions Legality of Fuel Price Hike

LAHORE: In the wake of recent hike in petroleum prices, Judicial Activism Forum has invoked…